Qafila Ecommece Fulfilment Log
Talk to an agent

FBM Vs FBA Vs FBN- Improving Your Profit Margin 

Introduction

Fulfillment costs can account for up to 20-30% of an e-commerce business’s total expenses. For sellers on platforms like Noon or Amazon, choosing the right fulfillment strategy is crucial to maximizing profits. While Fulfillment by Noon (FBN) and Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) offer convenience, they often come with high fees that can eat into your margins. On the flip side, Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM), a cost-effective alternative gives sellers more control over their operations.  

In this blog, we’ll explore how FBM can help you maximize profits on Noon or Amazon. We’ll break down the costs associated with FBN and FBA, compare them to FBM, and provide actionable tips to help you decide which fulfillment model is right for your business. 

Understanding Fulfillment Models

FBN (Fulfilled by Noon)

FBN is a service where Noon handles the entire fulfillment process, from storage to delivery. Sellers send their inventory to Noon’s warehouses, and Noon takes care of packing, shipping, and customer service.  

Key Features:  

  • Same-day or next-day delivery in key regions.  
  • Hassle-free returns and customer service. 

Benefits:  

  • Reduced operational burden.  
  • Access to Noon’s extensive logistics network. 

FBA (Fulfilled by Amazon)

FBA works similarly to FBN but on Amazon’s platform. Sellers send their inventory to Amazon’s fulfillment centers, and Amazon handles storage, packing, and shipping.  

Key Features:  

  • Prime eligibility for faster delivery.  
  • Access to Amazon’s global customer base. 

Benefits:  

  • Trusted fulfillment service.  
  • Enhanced customer trust and satisfaction. 

FBM (Fulfilled by Merchant)

FBM is a model where sellers handle their own fulfillment of orders from e-retailer platforms like Noon and Amazon. This includes storing inventory, packing orders, and shipping them directly to customers.  

Key Features:  

  • Full control over inventory and packaging.  
  • Flexibility to choose shipping carriers. 

Benefits:  

  • Lower fees for high-volume sellers.  
  • Direct customer interaction and relationship building. 

Cost Comparison: FBN vs. FBA vs. FBM

To understand which fulfillment model is the most cost-effective, let’s break down the fees associated with each:  

Fee Category 

FBN 

FBA 

FBM 

Referral Fees 

5-15% of sale price 

6-15% of sale price 

5-15% of sale price 

Storage Fees 

$0.75-$1.50 per cubic foot/month 

$0.75-$2.40 per cubic foot/month 

Seller’s own storage costs 

Pick and Pack Fees 

$1-$3 per unit 

$2-$5 per unit 

Seller’s own labor costs 

Shipping Fees 

Included in FBN fees 

Included in FBA fees 

Seller’s negotiated rates 

Long-Term Storage Fees 

$6.90 per cubic foot after 6 months 

$6.90 per cubic foot after 6 months 

N/A 

Additional Fees 

Returns handling, labeling 

Returns handling, labeling 

Seller’s own costs 

Analysis:  

  • FBN and FBA are convenient but come with higher fees, especially for long-term storage and additional services.  
  • FBM can be more cost-effective for sellers with efficient logistics, as it eliminates many of the fees associated with FBN and FBA. 

Pros and Cons of Each Fulfillment Method

Fulfillment by Noon (FBN)

Pros:

Localized Fulfillment

FBN is specifically designed for the Middle East, offering localized fulfillment that caters to regional preferences. This includes faster delivery times and culturally relevant customer service. 

For example, during Ramadan, FBN ensures timely deliveries after sunset, which is crucial for customer satisfaction in the MENA region. 

Faster Delivery in the MENA Region

FBN’s logistics network enables same-day or next-day delivery in key markets like the UAE, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt. This speed is a significant competitive advantage, especially in a region where customers value fast shipping. 

Reduced Operational Burden

Noon handles storage, packing, shipping, and customer service, allowing sellers to focus on growing their business. This is particularly beneficial for small businesses or sellers who lack the resources to manage logistics. 

Enhanced Customer Satisfaction

With reliable delivery and hassle-free returns, FBN helps build customer trust and loyalty. Happy customers are more likely to leave positive reviews and make repeat purchases. 

Cons:

Limited to Noon’s Marketplace

FBN is exclusive to Noon’s platform, meaning you can’t use it for sales on other marketplaces or your own website. This limits your flexibility if you want to diversify your sales channels. 

Higher Fees in Some Regions

While FBN offers convenience, its fees—such as storage, fulfillment, and long-term storage fees—can add up, especially for slow-moving inventory. For example, long-term storage fees can be as high as $6.90 per cubic foot after six months. 

Less Control Over Branding

FBN handles packaging and shipping, which means you have limited control over how your products are presented to customers. This can be a drawback for brands that want to create a unique unboxing experience. 

Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA)

Pros:

Prime Eligibility

Products fulfilled by Amazon are eligible for Prime, which offers fast, free shipping to millions of Amazon Prime members. This can significantly boost your sales, as Prime members tend to favor Prime-eligible products. 

Access to Amazon’s Global Customer Base

FBA gives you access to Amazon’s vast customer base, including international markets. This is a huge advantage if you’re looking to expand your reach beyond your local region. 

Trusted Fulfillment Service

Amazon’s reputation for reliable and efficient fulfillment can enhance customer trust in your brand. Many customers prefer buying products fulfilled by Amazon due to its proven track record. 

Cons:

High Fees

FBA’s fees, including storage, fulfillment, and long-term storage fees, can be expensive, especially for low-margin products. For example, storage fees can range from 0.75to0.75to2.40 per cubic foot per month, depending on the time of year.

Less Control Over Inventory

Once your inventory is in Amazon’s fulfillment centers, you have limited control over how it’s managed. This can be problematic if you need to make quick adjustments to your inventory strategy. 

Challenges with Oversized or Slow-Moving Items

FBA charges higher fees for oversized items and imposes long-term storage fees for slow-moving inventory. This can eat into your profits if you’re not careful with inventory management. 

Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM)

Pros

Greater Control Over Operations

With FBM, you have full control over inventory, packaging, and shipping. This allows you to customize the customer experience, from personalized packaging to branded inserts. 

Lower Fees for High-Volume Sellers

FBM can be more cost-effective than FBN or FBA, especially for high-volume sellers with efficient logistics. You avoid many of the fees associated with FBN and FBA, such as storage and fulfillment fees. 

Direct Customer Interaction

FBM allows you to interact directly with customers, which can enhance loyalty and brand perception. For example, you can include thank-you notes or special offers in your packages to encourage repeat purchases. 

Flexibility to Choose Shipping Carriers

You can negotiate better shipping rates with carriers or choose the most cost-effective option for each order. This flexibility can help you reduce shipping costs and improve profitability. 

Cons:

Requires More Effort

FBM requires you to manage all aspects of fulfillment, including storage, packing, and shipping. This can be time-consuming and complex, especially for small businesses or startups. 

Potential for Slower Delivery

Without the logistics infrastructure of FBN or FBA, you may struggle to match their delivery speeds. This can be a disadvantage in markets where customers expect fast shipping. 

Higher Risk of Errors

Managing your own fulfillment increases the risk of errors, such as shipping the wrong product or missing delivery deadlines. These mistakes can lead to negative reviews and lost sales. 

Why Fulfillment Method Matters for Profitability

Fulfillment costs directly impact your profit margins. While FBN and FBA offer convenience, their fees can significantly reduce your earnings, especially for low-margin products. On the other hand, FBM allows you to control costs and optimize your fulfillment process, making it a more profitable option in many cases.  

Trade-Offs:  

  • Control vs. Convenience: FBM gives you more control but requires more effort.  
  • Cost vs. Speed: FBN and FBA offer faster delivery but at a higher cost. 

When to Choose FBM Over FBA or FBN

  • High-Volume Sellers with Established Logistics: If you already have an efficient logistics network, FBM can save you money by eliminating FBN or FBA fees.  
  • Sellers with Unique Packaging Needs: FBM allows you to customize packaging, which is ideal for brands that want to enhance their unboxing experience.  
  • Sellers Looking to Reduce Fulfillment Costs: For low-margin or slow-moving products, FBM can be more cost-effective than FBN or FBA.  

Tips to Maximize Profits with FBM

  • Partner with reliable carriers and negotiate bulk shipping rates to reduce costs.  
  • Invest in tools like TradeGecko or Cin7 to streamline inventory management and avoid stockouts.  
  • Use lightweight, cost-effective packaging materials to reduce shipping costs.  
  • FBM is ideal for products that incur high storage fees in FBN or FBA warehouses. So, leverage it for slow-moving or oversized items. 

Qafila Can Help Optimize FBM Profits

For sellers leveraging Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM) on platforms like Amazon and Noon, partnering with an expert like Qafila can significantly enhance profitability while maintaining control over the fulfillment process. Qafila offers a suite of tailored services designed to streamline FBM operations, reduce overhead costs, and elevate customer satisfaction.  

By integrating advanced technology and a robust logistics network, Qafila empowers sellers to optimize their fulfilment, ensuring fast, reliable deliveries that meet the high expectations of Amazon and Noon customers. This partnership allows sellers to focus on scaling their business and refining their product offerings, all while keeping fulfillment costs in check and maximizing profit margins. 

Qafila’s specialized FBM solutions address key pain points for sellers, providing tools and support to boost efficiency and competitiveness. Key advantages of working with Qafila include: 

  • Cost Optimization: Transparent pricing and efficient logistics reduce shipping and storage costs, particularly for high-volume or oversized items, improving overall profitability. 
  • Seamless Platform Integration: Qafila’s systems integrate with Amazon Seller Central and Noon’s seller portal, enabling real-time order tracking and inventory updates to prevent stockouts or delays. 
  • Flexible Shipping Options: Access to expedited and economy shipping ensures sellers can offer competitive delivery times, enhancing customer satisfaction and repeat purchases. 
  • Enhanced Branding Opportunities: Custom packaging and labeling options allow sellers to strengthen their brand identity, fostering customer loyalty on both platforms. 
  • Proactive Customer Support: Qafila’s dedicated team handles returns, refunds, and inquiries swiftly, helping maintain high seller ratings and compliance with platform standards. 

Conclusion

Choosing the right fulfillment model is critical to maximizing profits on Noon or Amazon. While FBN and FBA offer convenience, their high fees can eat into your margins. Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM) provides a cost-effective alternative for sellers with efficient logistics and a desire for greater control.  

You May Also Like

OTIF Retail Compliance and Its Impact on UAE Market

OTIF Retail Compliance and Its Impact on UAE Market

Fastest Growing E-Commerce Hub of The Middle East  Introduction Things are no longer the way they were several years ago. The evolution of the world system and time has also impacted the way products are traded, giving rise to the booming e-commerce industry. The e-commerce industry is growing at a fast pace as everyone seeks […]

How to Ship Clothes Internationally: A Comprehensive Guide for E-Commerce Businesses 

How to Ship Clothes Internationally: A Comprehensive Guide for E-Commerce Businesses 

Expanding Your Business by Outsourcing the E-Commerce Fulfilment   Introduction Are you looking to deliver the latest fashion and accessories across the globe? Do you want to introduce your new trends instantly to your audience to stay ahead of the competition? This guide will help you, as an entrepreneur and business owner, understand how to deliver […]

How Digitization and E-Commerce Are Reshaping Freight Forwarding 

How Digitization and E-Commerce Are Reshaping Freight Forwarding 

Establishing E-Commerce Logistics for a Startup in the UAE: A Comprehensive Guide  Introduction E-commerce is revolutionizing the logistics industry, transforming it from the ground up. With unique standards and innovative technologies, e-commerce has reshaped logistics and supply chains, making them more dynamic, coordinated, and tech-friendly than ever before. One notable area of transformation is how […]

How 3PL Can Help Overcome E-Commerce Challenges 

How 3PL Can Help Overcome E-Commerce Challenges 

Enhancing Order Fulfillment in Food & Beverage E-Commerce  Introduction The e-commerce industry faces numerous challenges, but partnering with an experienced 3PL e-commerce fulfillment provider can significantly alleviate these issues. 3PL providers offer essential support to e-commerce businesses, helping them navigate and overcome obstacles efficiently.  Let’s explore some common challenges and how 3PL e-commerce fulfillment providers […]

First B2B, Now B2C: E-Commerce Is Taking Over 

First B2B, Now B2C: E-Commerce Is Taking Over 

Enhancing Customer Experience Through Your E-Commerce Supply Chain Introduction The Covid-19 pandemic has resulted in a dynamic shift of commerce from the offline to the online sphere. Both consumers and businesses pivoted towards the digital forum, albeit for varying reasons.  Thanks to technology, consumers’ purchasing behavior is directed towards online shopping, learning, and working. Businesses […]

Fastest Growing E-Commerce Hub of The Middle East 

Fastest Growing E-Commerce Hub of The Middle East 

E-Commerce Surge in the GCC- Navigating the New Landscape  Introduction Ever since the foundation of the United Arab Emirates (UAE) in 1971, the region has experienced dynamic geographic changes. The UAE is strategically located in the Middle East between Oman and Saudi Arabia, on the south-eastern shores of the Arabian Gulf, on the western shores […]